Hello and welcome to CertForums.co.uk, here we host free active certification forums with links to the best free resources for Microsoft's MCSA MCSE MCDBA Cisco's CCNA CCDA and CCNP, and CompTIA's A+ Network+ i-NET+ and Security+ certifications in the UK. If you wish to post or use other advanced features you will need to register first. Registration is absolutely free and takes only a few minutes to complete so sign up today!

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact support

Go Back   CertForums > Certification Forums > Cisco Certification Forums > General
Home Forums Register Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

study for a CCNA without work experience??

Post New ThreadReply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 10:28 AM
demarrer demarrer is offline
New Member
Posts: 42
Points: 0 demarrer has no points
Power: 2
None
Join Date: 07 Dec 2007
Location: Paris
Certifications: A+
study for a CCNA without work experience??

Hi,

I have been looking at becoming CCNA qualified... however as yet I have no previous work experience in an IT environment ( at the moment). Would you guys recommend studying for a CCNA cold or do you honestly need experience before you start with this? Also, by being CCNA qualified is this a good way into getting a first job?

H

 
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 10:34 AM
greenbrucelee's Avatar
greenbrucelee greenbrucelee is offline
Premium Member
Posts: 7,119
Points: 1522 greenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 pointsgreenbrucelee has over 1500 points
Power: 89
Join Date: 21 Mar 2007
Location: Carlisle Cumbria
Age: 31
Certifications: A+
WIP: N+
You should definatley NOT go for the CCNA you should have about a years experience with CISCO kits in a real job before attempting this, the majority of employers will bin your application if you say you have CCNA but no experience.

You should start with compTIA A+ then N+ the MCDST and get real experience before getting any other certs.


HND Bussiness Computing, GNVQ IT, NVQ 1 & 2 IT, A+
 
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 10:58 AM
wagnerk's Avatar
wagnerk wagnerk is online now CertForums News Posting Member
Lifetime Member
Posts: 3,262
Points: 2013 wagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 pointswagnerk has over 2000 points
Power: 58
Join Date: 13 May 2005
Location: Northants, UK
Age: 30
Certifications: 2nd Degree Black Belt
WIP: 70-647 (last exam for MCITP: EA)
I agree with GBL, however if you really want a Cisco cert, look into Cisco's entry level cert: the CCENT, after the Network+

-Ken


The Martial Arts: The more you sweat in practice, the less you bleed in battle.

My Community Profile
 
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 11:06 AM
demarrer demarrer is offline
New Member
Posts: 42
Points: 0 demarrer has no points
Power: 2
None
Join Date: 07 Dec 2007
Location: Paris
Certifications: A+
Cheers thanks for this information. There is just so much info out there ist a little hard to know where to start.
Would you know how long it would take to become compTIA A+ then N+ certified?

Cheers

 
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 02:50 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Premium Member
Posts: 9,937
Points: 4640 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 149
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 38
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by wagnerk View Post
I agree with GBL, however if you really want a Cisco cert, look into Cisco's entry level cert: the CCENT, after the Network+

-Ken
Even the CCENT shouldn't be attempted until you get some real-world IT experience. Just because it's Cisco's lowest-level cert, it should by no means be considered a certification for people just starting out in IT.

Start out with the A+ and Network+ while looking for an entry-level job. In time, you'll eventually work your way up to the point where you're ready for the CCENT and CCNA.


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 07-Dec-2007, 02:52 PM
BosonMichael's Avatar
BosonMichael BosonMichael is offline
Premium Member
Posts: 9,937
Points: 4640 BosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 pointsBosonMichael has over 4000 points
Power: 149
None
Join Date: 02 Nov 2006
Location: near Nashville, TN
Age: 38
Certifications: MCSE+I, MCSE: Securi.. huh? out of room?
WIP: Just about everything!
Quote:
Originally Posted by demarrer View Post
Cheers thanks for this information. There is just so much info out there ist a little hard to know where to start.
Would you know how long it would take to become compTIA A+ then N+ certified?

Cheers
How long it takes is completely up to you. Some people don't need to study... some people need years to study. It depends on how well you learn new things, your previous experience with computers, the amount of free time you have to study, etc. Everyone is different.


BosonMichael
MCSE+I, MCSE: Security, MCDST, MCDBA, OCP, CCNP, CCDP, CNE, SCSA, Security+, Linux+, Server+, Network+, A+
Served proudly, US Army, 98C Intelligence Analyst, '89-'92
 
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 10:34 AM
ciscopaul's Avatar
ciscopaul ciscopaul is offline
New Member
Posts: 24
Points: 73 ciscopaul has disabled reputation
Power: 8
None
Join Date: 13 Apr 2004
Hi H,

I have lost count of how many people have used the CCNA to make a career change into IT (including myself from the police). Everyone tried to tell me that it wasn't allowed but whenever you try to do something worthwhile there will be a number of people telling you that you can't do it.

You certainly can use the CCNA to gain work so I would ignore the army of people who try to convince you otherwise. If you study hard and do lots of hands on to prepare you will be able to do basic configs on routers and switches plus disaster recovery and backing up router and switch configs.

There are a large number of employers looking for full time staff or freelancers who are self motivated to study and have a good attitude. I had a student a couple of months ago fly over from Africa, do a CCNA course and the next week he went for 5 interviews and got an IT support job with a firm of lawyers. He hadn't even passed the exam yet.

Do you really want to waste a year of your life doing A+, Net+ etc when you could be doing some sort of network support role as a CCNA? If you want a list of companies who do employ CCNA engineers then look at ISPs and telcos. I was at Tiscali the other day and they are looking for keen people who are willing to learn.

These forums are rife with people telling you what you can and can't do with your life and 99% of what they tell you is simply not correct. How would they know anyway? Most have been in the same job for years and haven't been out for interviews for quite some time. They sit in forums all day long repeating the same tired old advice to the poor souls who have come for a bit of support and inspiration.

No doubt there will be lots of people disagreeing with me but the truth is very simple. You can do the CCNA or CCENT and go and get a job or contract soon after. It will probably be basic network support and you won't be configuring live kit but there are pleny of support roles where you can get involved in network monitoring where you won't be allowed enough access to break anything.

Best of luck.

Paul


Paul Browning LLB(Hons), CCNP, MCSE, A+, Net+
 
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 10:57 AM
Sparky's Avatar
Sparky Sparky is online now
Premium Member
Posts: 5,001
Points: 2421 Sparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 pointsSparky has over 2000 points
Power: 79
None
Join Date: 15 Dec 2005
Location: Scotland
Age: 29
Certifications: MSc MCSE MCTS N+ A+
WIP: Server 2008 upgrade & 70-284
Quote:
Originally Posted by ciscopaul View Post
These forums are rife with people telling you what you can and can't do with your life and 99% of what they tell you is simply not correct. How would they know anyway? Most have been in the same job for years and haven't been out for interviews for quite some time. They sit in forums all day long repeating the same tired old advice to the poor souls who have come for a bit of support and inspiration.

<sigh> What a load of BS.

Why are you dismissing the A+ and Network+ as a waste of time?

I spoke to a guy a few months ago who was looking for a job, he said he had passed the CCNA cert and had no commercial experience, he wanted £30k starting wage. I thought he was joking, turns out he wasn’t!


Me: You need to buy a couple of servers.
Customer: Whats wrong with the servers I have?
Me: Well, you dont have *any* servers just now.
Customer: WTF! I thought I did!

 
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 12:54 PM
onoski's Avatar
onoski onoski is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 1,448
Points: 456 onoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 points
Power: 21
None
Join Date: 08 Mar 2007
Location: London. UK
Certifications: MCP, HNC Business IT
WIP: MCSE 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by ciscopaul View Post
Hi H,

I have lost count of how many people have used the CCNA to make a career change into IT (including myself from the police). Everyone tried to tell me that it wasn't allowed but whenever you try to do something worthwhile there will be a number of people telling you that you can't do it.

You certainly can use the CCNA to gain work so I would ignore the army of people who try to convince you otherwise. If you study hard and do lots of hands on to prepare you will be able to do basic configs on routers and switches plus disaster recovery and backing up router and switch configs.

There are a large number of employers looking for full time staff or freelancers who are self motivated to study and have a good attitude. I had a student a couple of months ago fly over from Africa, do a CCNA course and the next week he went for 5 interviews and got an IT support job with a firm of lawyers. He hadn't even passed the exam yet.

Do you really want to waste a year of your life doing A+, Net+ etc when you could be doing some sort of network support role as a CCNA? If you want a list of companies who do employ CCNA engineers then look at ISPs and telcos. I was at Tiscali the other day and they are looking for keen people who are willing to learn.

These forums are rife with people telling you what you can and can't do with your life and 99% of what they tell you is simply not correct. How would they know anyway? Most have been in the same job for years and haven't been out for interviews for quite some time. They sit in forums all day long repeating the same tired old advice to the poor souls who have come for a bit of support and inspiration.

No doubt there will be lots of people disagreeing with me but the truth is very simple. You can do the CCNA or CCENT and go and get a job or contract soon after. It will probably be basic network support and you won't be configuring live kit but there are pleny of support roles where you can get involved in network monitoring where you won't be allowed enough access to break anything.

Best of luck.

Paul

Amen to the above Paul, too often certain people on this forum come across with a negative feedback and how they know everything and anything related to IT. Please, let there be some balance as we all started from somewhere with regards to our IT careers. I know someone who worked hard to gain he's CCNA then CCNP and now works as a "network engineer".

Obviously, the certs helped as he also learnt the hands practical way through use of router simulation. He then landed a helpdesk role with telecoms firm and after 3 yrs he's the man with a role title of "network engineer". I am in no way advocating brain dumpers either, just the good hard working determined way.

Remember, we all were given the chance through learning to prove out worth and hence we're what we are in terms of ITer's. I get a bit concerned when most people on CF are quick to pounce on the issue of no experience and a person trying to get a cert.

Even without being a genious we all know a cert is just a tool to get you to the interview table. Nuff said

 
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 01:33 PM
ffreeloader's Avatar
ffreeloader ffreeloader is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 3,649
Points: 3030 ffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 points
Power: 72
None
Join Date: 26 Jul 2005
Location: USA
Age: 54
Certifications: MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA, A+
WIP: LPIC 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparky View Post
<sigh> What a load of BS.

Why are you dismissing the A+ and Network+ as a waste of time?

I spoke to a guy a few months ago who was looking for a job, he said he had passed the CCNA cert and had no commercial experience, he wanted £30k starting wage. I thought he was joking, turns out he wasn’t!
Because he has a web site that sells stuff related to Cisco certifications. That's why. IOW's he has an agenda that benefits himself.



Behold, the turtle. He makes progress only when he sticks his neck out.

James Bryant Conant
 
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 01:38 PM
ffreeloader's Avatar
ffreeloader ffreeloader is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 3,649
Points: 3030 ffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 points
Power: 72
None
Join Date: 26 Jul 2005
Location: USA
Age: 54
Certifications: MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA, A+
WIP: LPIC 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by onoski View Post
Amen to the above Paul, too often certain people on this forum come across with a negative feedback and how they know everything and anything related to IT. Please, let there be some balance as we all started from somewhere with regards to our IT careers. I know someone who worked hard to gain he's CCNA then CCNP and now works as a "network engineer".

Obviously, the certs helped as he also learnt the hands practical way through use of router simulation. He then landed a helpdesk role with telecoms firm and after 3 yrs he's the man with a role title of "network engineer". I am in no way advocating brain dumpers either, just the good hard working determined way.

Remember, we all were given the chance through learning to prove out worth and hence we're what we are in terms of ITer's. I get a bit concerned when most people on CF are quick to pounce on the issue of no experience and a person trying to get a cert.

Even without being a genious we all know a cert is just a tool to get you to the interview table. Nuff said
When people who are in the business of selling certification related materials come here saying certs will get you a job without experience, well, I for one really tend to discount their stories. Take a look around this site and count the number of people who have gotten a cert and a job, simply because they got a cert, especially a higher level cert like a CCNA where they would have been placed in a position where they could possibly kill their employer's ability to do business with their mistakes.

Show me the number above, and then we'll look around at all the posts of people who have gotten certs, and then spent a long time finding a job. We'll see which group outnumbers the other by at least a margin of 20 or 30 to 1.



Behold, the turtle. He makes progress only when he sticks his neck out.

James Bryant Conant
 
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 04:08 PM
onoski's Avatar
onoski onoski is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 1,448
Points: 456 onoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 pointsonoski has over 250 points
Power: 21
None
Join Date: 08 Mar 2007
Location: London. UK
Certifications: MCP, HNC Business IT
WIP: MCSE 2003
Quote:
Originally Posted by ffreeloader View Post
When people who are in the business of selling certification related materials come here saying certs will get you a job without experience, well, I for one really tend to discount their stories. Take a look around this site and count the number of people who have gotten a cert and a job, simply because they got a cert, especially a higher level cert like a CCNA where they would have been placed in a position where they could possibly kill their employer's ability to do business with their mistakes.

Show me the number above, and then we'll look around at all the posts of people who have gotten certs, and then spent a long time finding a job. We'll see which group outnumbers the other by at least a margin of 20 or 30 to 1.

Freddy, I think we'd both agree as neither of us are in HR or directly involved in the decision making process. I did not advocate getting a high level cert such as the CCNA or CCNP would land anyone a job from the on set. I did however, say that it helps you land an interview and eventually a helpdesk type role where there would be potential to learn and move on.

 
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 08:29 PM
ffreeloader's Avatar
ffreeloader ffreeloader is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 3,649
Points: 3030 ffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 pointsffreeloader has over 3000 points
Power: 72
None
Join Date: 26 Jul 2005
Location: USA
Age: 54
Certifications: MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA, A+
WIP: LPIC 1
Quote:
Originally Posted by onoski View Post
Freddy, I think we'd both agree as neither of us are in HR or directly involved in the decision making process. I did not advocate getting a high level cert such as the CCNA or CCNP would land anyone a job from the on set. I did however, say that it helps you land an interview and eventually a helpdesk type role where there would be potential to learn and move on.
To tell the truth, I'm not even sure certs will get a person to an interview. Soft skills, the ability to communicate well in writing, experience working with people, recommendations to the company from acquaintances, a resume showing stability and upward progress in another field, a cover letter showing an applicant did their homework about the company and showing a real desire to work, etc... all of these things will get a career changer/someone-just-out-of-school to an interview long before a certification will.

My years of job hunting showed me the value of certs, and the value of being able to show verifiable experience and soft skills. The first was non-existent. The latter two valuable, and the stuff I put in my first paragraph got me to a lot of interviews. I always got beaten out by experience in those interviews, but I know my cover letters, name dropping of common acquaintances, homework about the company itself, and emphasizing my desire to work got me much more interest than my certifications did. I know. I asked what sparked interest, and what I needed to work on, after many of my failed interviews. Not a single employer told me to get more certifications. A lot them had helpful hints, but getting certs was never mentioned.



Behold, the turtle. He makes progress only when he sticks his neck out.

James Bryant Conant
 
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 08:41 PM
drum_dude's Avatar
drum_dude drum_dude is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 1,035
Points: 773 drum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 points
Power: 24
None
Join Date: 23 Dec 2004
Location: Solihull, Birmingham
Age: 33
Certifications: MCSA W2K , N+, A+ , ITIL Foundation
WIP: CCNA and Vista MCTS I think?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ciscopaul View Post
Hi H,

I have lost count of how many people have used the CCNA to make a career change into IT (including myself from the police). Everyone tried to tell me that it wasn't allowed but whenever you try to do something worthwhile there will be a number of people telling you that you can't do it.

You certainly can use the CCNA to gain work so I would ignore the army of people who try to convince you otherwise. If you study hard and do lots of hands on to prepare you will be able to do basic configs on routers and switches plus disaster recovery and backing up router and switch configs.

There are a large number of employers looking for full time staff or freelancers who are self motivated to study and have a good attitude. I had a student a couple of months ago fly over from Africa, do a CCNA course and the next week he went for 5 interviews and got an IT support job with a firm of lawyers. He hadn't even passed the exam yet.

Do you really want to waste a year of your life doing A+, Net+ etc when you could be doing some sort of network support role as a CCNA? If you want a list of companies who do employ CCNA engineers then look at ISPs and telcos. I was at Tiscali the other day and they are looking for keen people who are willing to learn.

These forums are rife with people telling you what you can and can't do with your life and 99% of what they tell you is simply not correct. How would they know anyway? Most have been in the same job for years and haven't been out for interviews for quite some time. They sit in forums all day long repeating the same tired old advice to the poor souls who have come for a bit of support and inspiration.

No doubt there will be lots of people disagreeing with me but the truth is very simple. You can do the CCNA or CCENT and go and get a job or contract soon after. It will probably be basic network support and you won't be configuring live kit but there are pleny of support roles where you can get involved in network monitoring where you won't be allowed enough access to break anything.

Best of luck.

Paul
What a complete crock of ****e!


 
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 09-Dec-2007, 08:44 PM
drum_dude's Avatar
drum_dude drum_dude is offline
Lifetime Member
Posts: 1,035
Points: 773 drum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 pointsdrum_dude has over 500 points
Power: 24
None
Join Date: 23 Dec 2004
Location: Solihull, Birmingham
Age: 33
Certifications: MCSA W2K , N+, A+ , ITIL Foundation
WIP: CCNA and Vista MCTS I think?
Quote:
Originally Posted by onoski View Post
Amen to the above Paul, too often certain people on this forum come across with a negative feedback and how they know everything and anything related to IT. Please, let there be some balance as we all started from somewhere with regards to our IT careers. I know someone who worked hard to gain he's CCNA then CCNP and now works as a "network engineer".

Obviously, the certs helped as he also learnt the hands practical way through us